【Carly Gregg’s Stepfather】Hidden Life and Dark Secrets Revealed in Court

A Sweet Little Girl Turned Tragic: The Trial of Carly Gregg

The courtroom sat silent as Heath Smylie, the stepfather of Carly Madison Gregg, recounted the horrifying day his family was torn apart. Carly, 15, now stands accused of killing her mother, Ashley Smylie, and attempting to kill Heath in a harrowing incident that has left the community reeling. Heath described the tragic morning of March 19, 2024, when Carly shot him, leaving him in shock, confusion, and desperate for answers.

A Daughter, a Shot, and a Blur of Chaos

According to Heath’s emotional testimony, Carly seemed like her usual self on that fateful morning. “She looked normal, nothing was out of place,” he said. But when he returned home that afternoon, a single gunshot from Carly greeted him as he opened the door. “Everything happened in a blur,” Heath recounted as he described the intense struggle to disarm Carly, who had already shot him in the shoulder.

“She was screaming out of her mind, scared like she had seen a demon,” Heath said, his voice cracking with emotion. He searched the house for Ashley, terrified of what might have happened. In Carly’s bedroom, he found Ashley’s lifeless body, with a blood-soaked towel covering her face.

The Secret Life of Carly Gregg

As the trial unfolded, disturbing details of Carly’s double life emerged. Prosecutor Kathryn White Newman painted a picture of a teenager leading a hidden existence—one marked by secret burner phones, marijuana-laced vape pens, and a troubling history of mental health struggles. Carly, who once appeared to be a “sweet little girl,” allegedly asked a friend after the shooting, “Are you squeamish around dead bodies?”

Testimonies from Carly’s friends further revealed her descent into risky behavior. Her close friend, B.W., testified that Carly had invited her over right after the shooting, calmly showing her mother’s body. “She showed me where the other guns were and asked if I wanted to wait while she dealt with her stepdad,” B.W. revealed.

The Chilling Motive

Another friend, T.G., testified that Carly had previously alluded to wanting to kill her parents. In a chilling message, Carly allegedly said she planned to murder both Ashley and Heath, revealing the dark thoughts swirling inside her mind long before the tragic event took place.

Defense attorney Bridget Todd pushed back against the prosecution’s narrative, portraying Carly as a victim herself—an “exceptional child” who was suffering from a severe mental illness. Todd insisted that the events on March 19 were not premeditated but rather the result of Carly’s fragile mental state.

What Lies Ahead for Carly Gregg?

As the trial continues, the weight of Carly’s actions—and the potential consequences—loom large. If convicted, the young teen faces a life sentence, though her defense team continues to argue for a plea of insanity. The question remains: Was this a tragic accident caused by a mental health crisis, or was Carly Gregg’s secret life leading her down a deadly path all along?

Stay tuned as this shocking trial unfolds, revealing more about the mind of Carly Gregg and the tragic events that shattered her family forever.